Stabilizing a Transistor with Series or Shunt Resistance

A 10 Ω series resistor in 50 Ω limits every load the transistor sees to the r = 0.2 circle (center 0.167, radius 0.833). If that circle clears the unstable region, any passive load is safe. The cost is gain and, at the input, noise figure about equal to the added loss.

Engineer’s note: Put a series or shunt resistor right in the RF path and yes, the amplifier stops oscillating, but you pay in gain and noise figure, and that doesn't come back. In practice I'd rather put an RC network on the bias line, outside the RF path, so it only pulls down gain in the low-frequency region where the device is unstable.

For practitioners

A potentially unstable transistor has K < 1, or fails an equivalent test. It has a range of terminations that make it oscillate. You can avoid that range with a lossless matching network and hope the real loads stay well-behaved. Or you can add a resistor that makes the bad terminations physically impossible to reach. This article shows how to size that resistor on the Smith chart and what it costs you.

What a resistor does to the loads the transistor can see

Put a series resistance R_s between the transistor output and whatever comes next. The impedance the transistor sees is then

Zseen=Rs+Zext,Re(Zext)≥0Z_{\text{seen}} = R_s + Z_{\text{ext}}, \quad \text{Re}(Z_{\text{ext}}) \geq 0

Any passive external network has a non-negative real part. So Re(Z_seen) ≥ R_s, whatever the external network is: a filter, an antenna, a cable, a short or an open. The transistor can no longer see a load with less resistance than R_s.

A shunt resistor works the same way in the admittance picture. With a shunt conductance G across the port, every passive termination gives

Yseen=G+Yext,Re(Yseen)≥GY_{\text{seen}} = G + Y_{\text{ext}}, \quad \text{Re}(Y_{\text{seen}}) \geq G

The resistor never needs to "fix" the load. It only takes part of the Smith chart out of reach.

The constant-resistance circle as a boundary

On the Smith chart, all impedances with normalized resistance at least r lie on or inside the constant-resistance circle for r. In the reflection-coefficient plane, that circle is

∣Γ−r1+r∣=11+r\left| \Gamma - \frac{r}{1+r} \right| = \frac{1}{1+r}

The center is r/(1+r) on the real axis and the radius is 1/(1+r). The circle always passes through Γ = +1, the open circuit. Its other real-axis crossing is Γ = (r − 1)/(r + 1).

Worked example: R_s = 10 Ω in a 50 Ω system.

  • r = 10 / 50 = 0.2
  • center = 0.2 / 1.2 = 0.167
  • radius = 1 / 1.2 = 0.833
  • left crossing = 0.167 − 0.833 = −0.667, which matches (0.2 − 1)/(0.2 + 1) = −0.667
  • right crossing = 0.167 + 0.833 = +1.0

Every load the transistor can see through a 10 Ω series resistor lies inside this circle. That holds even if the external port is shorted. A short gives exactly Z = 10 Ω, or Γ = −0.667.

−100.167−0.667+1Re Γ|Γ| = 1normalized to Z0 = 50 Ωoutput (load)stability circleunstable loadsr = 0.2 circle (R_s = 10 Ω)center 0.167, radius 0.833all passive loads seenthrough R_s, R ≥ 10 Ωall loads with R ≥ 10 Ωare stable
The load stability circle and the r = 0.2 constant-resistance circle for a 10 Ω series resistor on a 50 Ω Smith chart: the resistance circle stays clear of the unstable region. Concept drawing.

The figure shows the useful case. The output stability circle cuts into the unit circle on the left side of the chart, near the short-circuit point. The unstable loads are shaded. The r = 0.2 circle stays completely clear of the shaded region. Every load the transistor can see through R_s therefore falls in the stable region.

The clearance test

The load stability circle has its usual center and radius:

CL=(S22−ΔS11∗)∗∣S22∣2−∣Δ∣2,rL=∣S12S21∣∣∣S22∣2−∣Δ∣2∣C_L = \frac{(S_{22} - \Delta S_{11}^*)^*}{|S_{22}|^2 - |\Delta|^2}, \quad r_L = \frac{|S_{12} S_{21}|}{\left| |S_{22}|^2 - |\Delta|^2 \right|}

Here Δ = S11 S22 − S12 S21. If |S11| < 1, the center of the chart (Γ_L = 0) is stable. In that case the unstable region is inside the stability circle when the circle does not enclose the origin, and outside it when it does.

Let c = r/(1+r) and ρ = 1/(1+r). For the usual case, where the unstable region is inside the stability circle, the resistance circle must not overlap it:

∣CL−c∣≥rL+ρ|C_L - c| \geq r_L + \rho

When the unstable region is outside the stability circle, the resistance circle must sit inside it:

∣CL−c∣+ρ≤rL|C_L - c| + \rho \leq r_L

To size the resistor, start at r = 0 and increase r until the test passes. The value where the two circles are just tangent is the minimum. Add margin, because S-parameters change with bias, temperature and part spread. Then repeat the test at every frequency where the device has gain, not only in your band. Out-of-band frequencies are where oscillations usually start.

The output check covers only half the problem. The whole amplifier is stable only if the source side passes the same test against the source stability circle. That check applies to whatever input network you use, resistive or not.

Series or shunt: which part of the chart you can protect

The geometry decides which type of resistor can work:

  • The series-resistance circle always touches Γ = +1. A series resistor therefore cannot stabilize a device whose unstable region reaches the open-circuit point. It works when the unstable region sits near the left of the chart, at low-resistance loads.
  • The shunt-conductance circle g = G/Y0 always touches Γ = −1. Its center is at −g/(1+g) and its radius is 1/(1+g). A shunt resistor works when the unstable region sits near the right of the chart, at high-impedance loads. It cannot help near a short.

Shunt example: a 250 Ω shunt resistor in a 50 Ω system gives G = 4 mS and g = 0.2. The circle has its center at −0.167 and radius 0.833, and it crosses the real axis at Γ = −1.0 and +0.667. It is the series example reflected through the origin.

What it costs: gain and noise

The resistor dissipates power, so gain drops. As a rough reference, a 10 Ω series resistor between two 50 Ω terminations has |S21| = 2Z0/(2Z0 + R) = 100/110. That is a loss of 20 log10(1.1) ≈ 0.83 dB. The 250 Ω shunt in the same setup gives the same 0.83 dB. In the real circuit the impedance levels differ, so compute the loss in your actual network.

Noise depends on where the resistor sits. A lossy element of loss L at room temperature has noise factor F = L. The Friis formula then gives:

Fin=L⋅Ft(resistor ahead of the transistor)F_{\text{in}} = L \cdot F_t \quad \text{(resistor ahead of the transistor)}
Fout=Ft+L−1Gt(resistor after the transistor)F_{\text{out}} = F_t + \frac{L - 1}{G_t} \quad \text{(resistor after the transistor)}

At the input, the noise figure rises by about the loss in dB. At the output, the transistor's available gain G_t divides down the penalty.

In an LNA, stabilize on the output side whenever the stability circles allow it. A resistor ahead of the transistor adds its full loss directly to the noise figure.

In plain words · for students and beginners

Stabilizing resistors in plain words

An everyday analogy

Think of a child on a swing next to a wall. Some swing angles make the child hit the wall. You could tell everyone to push gently and hope nobody pushes too hard. Or you could add a damper to the swing so that it can never reach the wall, no matter how hard anyone pushes. The stabilizing resistor is that damper. It wastes some energy, so the swing never goes quite as high as before.

The analogy breaks down in one place. A real damper slows every movement equally. A series resistor only blocks one part of the Smith chart, the low-resistance loads. If the trouble is somewhere else, such as near an open circuit, a series resistor cannot help, and you need a shunt resistor instead.

The same example in simple steps

The Smith chart is a map of every possible load, drawn as a disk. The reflection coefficient Γ is the position on that map.

  1. Pick a resistor: 10 Ω in series with the output. The system impedance Z0 is 50 Ω.
  2. Normalize it, meaning divide by Z0: r = 10/50 = 0.2.
  3. Find the circle that holds every load with at least this much resistance. Its center is 0.2/1.2 = 0.167 and its radius is 1/1.2 = 0.833.
  4. It crosses the horizontal axis at −0.667 and at +1.0.
  5. Draw the stability circle, which is the boundary of the loads that make the transistor oscillate. If the r = 0.2 circle never touches the unstable side, the resistor does its job.
(a) 10 Ω in series with loadTransistorR_s = 10 ΩLoadadds loss, reduces gain,calms the deviceat the input, the sameresistor would also raisenoise figure(b) Shunt R to groundTransistorShunt RLoadadds loss, reduces gain,calms the deviceat the input, the sameresistor would also raisenoise figure
Two ways to stabilize a transistor output with resistance: (a) a 10 Ω resistor in series with the load and (b) a resistor to ground in parallel with the load. Concept drawing.

The drawing shows both ways to do it. In (a) a 10 Ω resistor sits in series with the load. In (b) a resistor goes from the output to ground, in parallel with the load. Both add loss, reduce gain and calm the device. If you put the same resistor at the input, it would also raise the noise figure, which measures how much noise the amplifier adds.

Mistakes beginners make

  • Checking only one frequency. The transistor can oscillate at a frequency far from the one you care about. Check every frequency where it has gain.
  • Checking only one side. Making the output side safe is not enough. The input side needs its own check with the source stability circle.
  • Using a series resistor for an unstable region near the open circuit. The series-resistance circle always touches that point, so it can never clear it. Use a shunt resistor there.
  • Putting the resistor at the input of a low-noise amplifier. The noise figure gets worse by roughly the resistor's loss. That is usually the most expensive place for it.
  • Choosing a much bigger resistor than needed. Every extra ohm of series resistance costs gain. Use the smallest value that clears the unstable region, plus a little margin.

Remember

  • A series resistor R_s keeps every load the transistor sees inside the circle r = R_s/Z0. For 10 Ω in 50 Ω, the center is 0.167 and the radius is 0.833.
  • If that circle stays clear of the unstable region at every frequency, no passive load can make the output side oscillate. Check the input side as well.
  • The resistor always costs gain. At the input it also costs noise figure, about equal to its loss.

Frequently asked questions

How does a series resistor stabilize a transistor?

A series resistance R_s means every passive load the transistor sees has a real part of at least R_s. Those loads all lie inside the constant-resistance circle r = R_s/Z0. If that circle stays out of the unstable region of the stability circle, no passive load can push the device into oscillation.

How do I choose the value of a stabilizing resistor?

Draw the stability circle and increase r until the constant-resistance circle r = R_s/Z0 no longer touches the unstable region. The smallest value that clears it, plus some margin, gives the least gain loss.

Should the stabilizing resistor go at the input or the output?

Either one costs gain. A resistor at the input also raises noise figure by about the loss it adds. At the output, the transistor's gain reduces the resistor's noise contribution, so low-noise designs usually put the resistor on the output side.

When should I use a shunt resistor instead of a series resistor?

The series-resistance circle always touches Γ = +1, so it cannot keep the device away from instability near an open circuit. The shunt-conductance circle always touches Γ = −1, so it cannot help near a short circuit. Choose the type whose circle can avoid the unstable region you have.

References and further reading